You can now see the result of all my hard work (and whining). The five Linux distros I reviewed are online and conveniently in one roundup, so you can see them all: What Flavor of Linux is Right For You?
Linux Mint earned the Editor’s Choice, as well it should, as it was my favorite of the five. Ubuntu was a close second. As I mentioned before, I am not partial to PCLinuxOS or Mandriva, and Fedora makes me want to never see Linux again. (This is especially sad because Fedora is the one that works best with the Samsung netbooks.)
Click on over to read. Maybe you will find yourself thinking about trying Linux. I am glad I did, despite everything.
Up until a year ago when I bought my first Eee PC, I’d heard of Linux but never had a desire to use it. Not in its desktop form, at least. I’d dealt with Linux web servers before. Until last year, I was vaguely aware that Linux was an operating system that was free and an alternative to Windows, but it also seemed to me that Linux was mainly for people deeply into technology. Also people who didn’t mind jumping through a lot of hoops in order to do what I considered very simple tasks. Linux was not for me, I reasoned, and thus I ignored it.
I don’t think I’m all that different from most informed computer users. I use this funny box to do more than just check email and process words. My computer is central to my livelihood. And yet Linux held no temptation for me.
Then I got an Eee PC.
When I heard that Eee PCs came with Linux on them (a tweaked version of Xandros, as we all now know) I wasn’t put off. I was actually happy to hear it, because I figured not having Windows helped keep the cost down. After I bought it, I used that little netbook every day for months. In that case, I did mainly use it for surfing and writing and not much else. Still, Linux didn’t make things more difficult, trip me up, or otherwise annoy me. I actually enjoyed it. Plus, I will admit, it made me feel like an ubergeek, which is a good feeling.
When I interviewed for my current job I even said that I thought Linux was pretty awesome and would be willing to try it elsewhere. My boss hasn’t let me forget that yet. Especially in light of the last 5 weeks.
The other day I wrote a story about people putting Android–the Google operating system for phones–on netbooks. I can’t say that it was my most exciting assignment ever. I put porting Android to the EeePC on a long list of things people do just because they can. Possibly because it’s cool. Sometimes because they want to stretch their abilities and test their own limits. But the end result for everyone is not always practical. Yes, you can put Android on some netbooks, but it doesn’t work all that well and won’t connect to the app store/market, either.
Perhaps I’m being a bit curmudgeonly. I use my netbook to get work done, so I need it… working. But for developers, figuring out how to port things to different platforms and hardware is work. Still, I always look at news of this type with a bit of skepticism.
Yesterday Brad Linder (of Liliputing) and Adam McDaniel put up instructions on how to create a LiveUSB of the HP Mi Edition version of Linux (which is basically Ubuntu with some semi-extensive tweaks). This is big news for anyone interested in the Mi OS because up until now you could download it but the install would overwrite everything on your hard drive. Most Linuxes have the ability to make LiveCDs or LiveUSBs so you can try a distro out and, as far as I know, all of them can install alongside an existing OS (in theory). But I don’t know if HP expected there to be this kind of interest in the Mi Linux.
Anyway, Brad and Adam spent some time figuring out how to tweak things, so now anyone with a lot of time who isn’t turned off by using Terminal can spend an hour making a LiveUSB of this (admittedly sleek) OS. Does this fall into Because You Can? Maybe not. After all, the OS is usable and meant to run on a netbook. On the other hand: look at all this tech speak!
I’ve already been promised that I don’t have to do it.
I’m writing up reviews of 5 Linux distros for work and it’s killing me. Linux is both wonderful and completely frustrating, and resolving those two things is hard. Especially when I am trying to be objective. One thing I am really enjoying about some of the Linuxes is their ability to run from USB thumb drives so you can try them out without installing. I really, really love that, with some, the OS can save changes to said USB drive, so I can add programs, tweak settings, etc., and it will be there next time I boot up no matter what computer I’m on. Pocket OS — score!
I also installed the PortableApps platform on an SD card I had in my Eee PC (before I gave it to my niece for Christmas). PortableApps is amazing — lots of great, useful software on an SD card that, again, retains settings and information and leaves no trace behind on the computer you’re using. It’s great for security and supremely useful for me since I test a lot of netbooks and notebooks and don’t want to always install the same core programs over and over.
PortableApps utilizes all open source software, so there are many things I’m not entirely familiar with. But I’m taking it as an opportunity to learn about what’s out there. Of course I know all about Firefox and Thunderbird (which, by the way, everyone should be using instead of MS Office) and Open Office. I’m trying to evaluate whether KompoZer is an adequate substitute for Dreamweaver. GIMP isn’t adequate for anything, alas. There is a dearth of open source photo editing stuff. Someone please correct this!
Anyway, I’m getting very much into my portable OS and apps. Maybe, maybe, maybe it will facilitate my eventual switch to Linux, but I’m extremely dubious about that at this point. Mainly because I’ve had to deal with installing, configuring, and testing five distros in the past month and none of them have been easy or without problems. But that’s a post for another day.
K. T. Bradford
If code is poetry, then CSS is The Iliad. In the original Greek.
I write about and review mobile technology, which means I get to spend the day steeped in laptops, smartphones, tablets, eReaders, and other things that go beep. Lest you question my status as a ChicGeek, I'll proudly claim an unabashed love for netbooks, Linux, science fiction, and curly hair products. Currently I'm a reviewer for Tecca and Black Enterprise‘s Tech section.
New Tech
- The Long Path To Market For Lenovo’s Yoga Gives Me Hope I’ll See Other Devices I Want Someday
- Why Google+ Wants Your Real Name
- Sharing Contact Information Digitally: Why Isn’t This Easy For Android Phones?
- Liz Henry: The Best Apps for BlogHer ’11
- “You announce what kind of phone you have and you’ll spend the next hour enduring an obnoxious holy war”
Tagged Tech
accessories Acer Android Apple Apple Tablet apps ASUS ASUS UL30 ASUS UL30A being geeky clips code is poetry CULV processor Cute Tech facebook Fedora Firefox Google iPhone Journalism LAPTOP Magazine laptops linkedin Linux Linux Mint Mandriva Linux my reviews netbook netbooks notebook operating systems PCLinuxOS Samsung Samsung N110 Samsung NC10 Samsung NC10 Special Edition smartphones tablets tech Ubuntu ultraportable ULV processor USB Drives USB Hub web designOld Tech









